George Walter Thornbury, "The White Rose over the Water" in Songs of the Cavaliers and Roundheads, Jacobite Ballads, &c. &c. (1857)
“

The old men sat with hats pulled down,   Their claret cups before them: Broad shadows hid their sullen eyes,   The tavern lamps shone o’er them, As a brimming bowl, with crystal fill’d,   Came borne by the landlord’s daughter, Who wore in her bosom the fair white rose,   That grew best over the water.Then all leap’d up, and join’d their hands   With hearty clasp and greeting, The brimming cups, outstretch’d by all,   Over the wide bowl meeting. “A health,” they cried, “to the witching eyes   Of Kate, the landlord’s daughter! But don’t forget the white, white rose   That grows best over the water.”Each others’ cups they touch’d all round,   The last red drop outpouring; Then with a cry that warm’d the blood,   One heart-born chorus roaring— “Let the glass go round, to pretty Kate,   The landlord’s black-eyed daughter. But never forget the white, white rose   That grows best over the water.”Then hats flew up and swords sprang out,   And lusty rang the chorus— “Never,” they cried, “while Scots are Scots,   And the broad Frith’s before us.” A ruby ring the glasses shine   As they toast the landlord’s daughter, Because she wore the white, white rose   That grew best over the water.A poet cried, “Our thistle’s brave,   With all its stings and prickles; The shamrock with its holy leaf   Is spar’d by Irish sickles. But bumpers round, for what are these   To Kate, the landlord’s daughter, Who wears at her bosom the rose as white,   That grows best over the water?”They dash’d the glasses at the wall,   No lip might touch them after; The toast had sanctified the cups   That smash’d against the rafter; Then chairs thrown back, they up again,   To toast the landlord’s daughter. But never forgot the white, white rose   That grew best over the water.

— George Walter Thornbury on Jacobitism

What It Means

This is a placeholder explanation generated by the low-overhead model. It interprets "The old men sat with hats pulled down,   Their claret cups before them: Broad shadows hid their sullen eyes,   The tavern lamps shone o’er them, As a brimming bowl, with crystal fill’d,   Came borne by the landlord’s daughter, Who wore in her bosom the fair white rose,   That grew best over the water.Then all leap’d up, and join’d their hands   With hearty clasp and greeting, The brimming cups, outstretch’d by all,   Over the wide bowl meeting. “A health,” they cried, “to the witching eyes   Of Kate, the landlord’s daughter! But don’t forget the white, white rose   That grows best over the water.”Each others’ cups they touch’d all round,   The last red drop outpouring; Then with a cry that warm’d the blood,   One heart-born chorus roaring— “Let the glass go round, to pretty Kate,   The landlord’s black-eyed daughter. But never forget the white, white rose   That grows best over the water.”Then hats flew up and swords sprang out,   And lusty rang the chorus— “Never,” they cried, “while Scots are Scots,   And the broad Frith’s before us.” A ruby ring the glasses shine   As they toast the landlord’s daughter, Because she wore the white, white rose   That grew best over the water.A poet cried, “Our thistle’s brave,   With all its stings and prickles; The shamrock with its holy leaf   Is spar’d by Irish sickles. But bumpers round, for what are these   To Kate, the landlord’s daughter, Who wears at her bosom the rose as white,   That grows best over the water?”They dash’d the glasses at the wall,   No lip might touch them after; The toast had sanctified the cups   That smash’d against the rafter; Then chairs thrown back, they up again,   To toast the landlord’s daughter. But never forgot the white, white rose   That grew best over the water." in the context of "George Walter Thornbury, "The White Rose over the Water" in Songs of the Cavaliers and Roundheads, Jacobite Ballads, &c. &c. (1857)" to mean that wisdom is timeless.

Quote Image
Source: Wikiquote: "Jacobitism" (Quotes, In fiction) The 'What it means' explanation text was generated by Google Gemini Flash (accessed January 18, 2026). https://gemini.google.com/app
George Walter Thornbury

About George Walter Thornbury

George Walter Thornbury (13 November 1828 – June 11 1876) was an English author. He was the son of a London solicitor. A journalist by profession, he also wrote verse, novels, art criticism and popular historical and topographical sketches. He began his career in 1845 with contributions to Bristol Journal and wrote later mainly for the Athenaeum. He is said to have died in a lunatic asylum.